The Michigan Economic Development Corporation executive committee said Tuesday, Nov. 17, it would not renew a contract with the Michigan Israel Business Accelerator, a group that had been the target of calls to defund it in opposition to the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza.
The contract will not be renewed because of budget constraints, according to the agency.
Public commenters at Tuesday’s executive committee meeting thanked the MEDC for its decision but asked it also to commit to ending all relationships with the group, including funding that may stem from other economic development programs. While the decision ends MEDC’s corporate funding for the accelerator, it is still possible for MIBA to go through a competitive grant process for small business funding.
“Thank you for not funding MIBA for the 2027 cycle,” Judi Suess said during Tuesday’s public comment period. “We ask that the MEDC not award any future Michigan public funds to MIBA,” adding that such funding is “morally reprehensible.”
MIBA CEO Mark Davidoff said the Michigan-based nonprofit has appreciated its great relationship with the state over the past several years and plans to continue to create jobs for the people of Michigan.
“We totally understand the current budget constraints and we look forward to continuing to explore other opportunities with the incoming administration,” Davidoff said.
“There was a body of contracts not being renewed,” he said. “MIBA was not singled out and we’re not going anywhere.”
Other programs reduced in Tuesday’s meeting, in light of budget constraints, included the Technology Transfer Talent Network Program (T3N), the Michigan Small Business Innovation Research and Technology Transfer Assistance Program (MAP), the Michigan Translational Research and Commercialization Program (MTRAC) and the Emerging Technologies Fund Program (ETF), said MEDC spokeswoman Danielle Emerson.
At least $5.1 million has flowed through Michigan’s economic development agency since 2018 to MIBA, a nonprofit organization that aims to facilitate economic collaboration between Michigan and Israel. The relationship between MIBA and the MEDC dates back to Republican former Gov. Rick Snyder’s administration and is meant to encourage Israeli businesses to locate operations in Michigan.
Snyder told The News last month that the relationship between MIBA and the state began in 2018 as part of an effort to bring some of Israel’s technology startups to the state of Michigan.
“If you think about the natural marketplace for Israel, it’s not a large country, so they have to sell outside of Israel in terms of their technology,” Snyder said. “And I viewed Michigan to be a great gateway for them to establish a presence in Michigan to enter the U.S. market.”
The MEDC reduced its workforce by 15% in September due to a funding shortfall, in large part due to several tribal casinos discontinuing the fees they pay to the state over tensions related to online gaming. State lawmakers also have cut programmatic spending to the MEDC after criticizing its performance.
In October, the MEDC executive committee adopted scaled-back performance goals after the agency said its appropriated budget had decreased 36% since last year and the corporate budget was facing an unplanned $30 million shortfall.
Those budget pressures appear to have contributed to the decision to not renew MIBA grant funding for the first time in eight years.
In its most recent contract with MIBA, the MEDC agreed to pay $650,000 toward the Michigan Israel Business Accelerator, bringing the tally in state support for the group between 2018 and July 2026 to $5.1 million, according to state treasury records. Those state funds, CEO Davidoff has said, are matched through private charitable contributions to the group.
Over the last several months, a group called MI Money Out of MIBA has organized groups of public commenters who have lined up at Michigan Economic Development Corporation meetings to urge the state to part ways with the Israel-linked organization.
Complaints about the state’s support for MIBA heightened in September when the Michigan Strategic Fund announced it would award roughly $1 million to the U.S. entity of Capture Systems Ltd., an Israeli counter-drone company whose Michigan investments MIBA helped secure.
The group also counts among its economic development wins other less controversial businesses, such as a wood recycling operation in Muskegon, Daika Wood, and an autonomous driving tech company in Madison Heights, Mobileye, according to documentation submitted to the state.
The services provided to the state through the group, according to its 2026 contract, include the enhancement of “bilateral trade and investment relations between Michigan and Israel” and supporting the MEDC’s “strategic industries, small businesses and foreign direct investment in Michigan.”
That goal included efforts to increase connections between Michigan and Israel businesses, an expansion of the Israel companies participating in MIBA’s “landing zone” and coworking community in Detroit and the completion of four trade missions between Michigan and Israel.
Under its contract, MIBA must make a reasonable effort under the agreement to ensure technologies coming to Michigan from Israel are “additive” and don’t create direct competition with products already developed or sold by Michigan businesses.
eleblanc@detroitnews.com
This article originally appeared on The Detroit News: MEDC will not renew Michigan-Israel contract, cites budget constraints
Reporting by Beth LeBlanc, The Detroit News / The Detroit News
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect